West Virginia Family Legislative Update 2000
by Kevin McCoy, President, West Virginia Family Foundation
West Virginia's Senate did this year what no statewide elected body
had done before; it passed pro-homosexual legislation. On March 3, 2000
a total of 19 senators voted to pass SB 422, adding sexual orientation
and disability to the hate crime statute.
The homosexual lobby ardently supports hate crime legislation, which
is more aptly named the SPECIAL PRIVILEGES FOR HOMOSEXUALS bill. In
this past legislative session, the WV Lesbian and Gay Coalition, WV
Human Rights Commission, WV Attorney General's office and other agencies
worked intensely for passage of SB 422. This radical pro-homosexual
bill, if passed, would have made it a felony criminal offense with
penalties of up to 10 years in prison and $5,000 in fines for a
heterosexual convicted of "interfering with, harassing, oppressing, or
intimidating a homosexual". On the other hand, the same offense against
a heterosexual would remain a simple misdemeanor with minuscule jail
time and fines. The homosexuals' agenda is clear. By adding "sexual
orientation" as a "protected class" to West Virginia's hate crime laws,
homosexuals aim to silence Christian opposition to the homosexual
lifestyle.
The State Senate Roll Call Vote showed the following results: For hate
crime legislation (special privileges for homosexuals): Homer Ball (D),
Mercer; Truman Chafin (D), Mingo; Oshel Craigo (D), Putnam; Larry Edgell
(D), Wetzel; Walt Helmick (D), Pocahontas; Jon Blair Hunter (D),
Monongalia; Lloyd Jackson, II (D), Lincoln; Jeffrey Kessler (D),
Marshall; Brooks McCabe (D), Kanawha; John Mitchell, Jr. (D), Kanawha;
Michael Oliverio, II (D), Monongalia; Roman Prezioso, Jr. (D), Marion;
Marie Redd (D), Cabell; Mike Ross (D), Randolph; Herb Snyder (D),
Jefferson; John Unger, II (D), Berkeley; Martha Walker (D), Kanawha;
William Wooton (D), Raleigh; Earl Ray Tomblin (D), Logan.
State Senators voting against hate crime protections were Leonard
Anderson (D), Summers; Billy Wayne Bailey, Jr. (D), Wyoming; Donna Boley
(R), Pleasants; Edwin Bowman (D), Hancock; James Dawson (D), Clay; Frank
Deem (R), Wood; Robert Ditmar (D), Jackson; John Pat Fanning (D),
McDowell; Shirley Love (D), Fayette; Andy McKenzie (R), Ohio; Joseph
Minard (D), Harrison; Sarah Minear (R), Tucker; Robert Plymale (D),
Wayne; William Sharpe, Jr. (D), Lewis; Vic Sprouse (R), Kanawha.
On the House side, the hate crime bill never made it out of committee
to the floor for a vote. In the last days of the session, the bill came
up for a Judiciary Committee vote that would have moved it toward
passage in the House. With 22 of 25 committee members present, the vote
was split evenly down the middle, 11 to 11. Without a majority of votes
behind it, the bill "died" in committee. This is a CLEAR WARNING to the
Christian community that unless there is involvement in the political
process, the opposition intends to make criminals out of anyone who
opposes their ungodly lifestyle. And to make matters worse part of this
effort is being funded partly with state tax dollars through groups like
the WV Human Rights Commission. A House of Delegates Judiciary
Committee Roll Call Vote shows that the following voted for hate crime
protections (for special privileges for homosexuals): Jon Amores (D),
Kanawha; Mark Hunt (D), Kanawha; Tai Hutchins (D), Ohio; Arley Johnson
(D), Cabell; Virginia Mahan (D), Summers; Larry Rowe (D), Kanawha;
Robert Schadler (R), Mineral; Rick Staton (D), Wyoming; Joe Smith (D),
Kanawha; Randy White (D), Webster; Mark Wills (D), Mercer.
House of Delegates members who voted against hate crime protections
were Shelley Moore Capito (R), Kanawha; Tom Coleman (D), Taylor; Sammy
Dalton (D), Lincoln; Larry Faircloth (R), Berkeley; Roy Givens (D),
Brooke; Larry Linch (D), Harrison; Dale Riggs (R), Upshur; Jody Smirl
(R), Cabell; William Stemple (D), Calhoun; Charles "Rusty" Webb (R),
Kanawha; Gil White (R), Ohio.
Those absent during the vote were Joe Ferrell (D), Logan; Oscar Hines
(D), Roane; Sharon Spencer (D), Kanawha.
DEFENSE OF MARRIAGE
Since 1997, the "Defense of Marriage" bill has been introduced to ban
the recognition of same- sex marriages performed in other states.
Recognition of same-sex marriage has long been a part of the homosexual
agenda despite their denial. This year, however, Governor Cecil
Underwood introduced this bill as part of his legislative package, and
with the support of a handful of dedicated Christian men and women, the
state of West Virginia passed this bill into law on March 3, 2000. All
34 senators voted in favor of SB 146; the bill later passed the House
and was signed into law by the Governor.
Pro-homosexual delegates voting against the same-sex marriage ban were
Barbara Fleischauer (D), Monongalia County; Susan Hubbard (D), Cabell
County; Charlene Marshall (D), Monongalia County.